BVI, Caribbeanand International News

Lawmakers’ discretionary powers appropriate, review finds

Lawmakers’ discretionary powers appropriate, review finds

A recent review that stemmed from the Commission of Inquiry (COI) report has concluded that the discretionary powers granted to elected officials in various legislation are necessary, appropriate, and not overly broad or excessive.
The report, authored by local attorney Anthea Smith, includes a compilation of enactments in which elected public officials have been granted discretionary powers and an assessment of whether the discretionary powers granted are necessary or unnecessary, and whether they should be retained or removed.

It found that only a small number of provisions in a few enactments could potentially be challenged by way of constitutional motion.

Open to judicial challenge

The report’s conclusion highlighted three specific provisions that were identified as giving rise to the possibility of challenge. These include Section 57(2) of the Social Security (Employment Injury Benefits) Regulations, which allows the Minister to remove the chairman or any member of the Medical Appeals Tribunal without assigning any reason. Smith said this provision potentially compromises the independence of the tribunal because the Tribunal performs an adjudicatory function.

Another provision identified is Section 175(3) of the Public Finance Management Regulations 2005, which provides for the Cabinet to exercise discretion to accept or reject the recommendation of the Central Tenders Board. The report found that there is no guidance as to the criteria the Cabinet should take into account in exercising its discretion about the recommendations of the Central Tenders Board, which could potentially be subject to judicial review.

The matter of continued tender waivers by Cabinet over the years was a critical source of contention during the COI, with the government being accused up to late last year of still indiscriminately issuing tender waivers for government contracts.

Meanwhile, the report also highlighted Section 28 (3) of the Virgin Islands Investment Act, 2020, which empowers the Minister, on the advice of the Commission, to delay or prevent a foreign investor from transferring funds outside of the territory to prevent movements of capital that cause or threaten to cause serious difficulties for macroeconomic management of the economy. It further pointed out that, Section 25 of the Constitution confers protection from deprivation of any “interest in or right to or over property of any description,” except in certain listed circumstances. Deprivation for the purpose of preventing movements of capital for the safeguarding of the local economy, the review explained, is not included in that list.


More broadly, the report showed that the greater problem lies in areas of government statutes or regulations that do not clearly delineate a course of action, which places little if any, effective limit on the ability of public officials to act according to their inclinations without sufficient regard to the principles of good government.

In some cases, even where legislation sets out policy objectives and clear and principled approaches to the achievement of the same, elected representatives may ignore or bypass these. It contended that this gives rise to questions of enforcement and recommended supplemental legislation to provide clarity as to the purpose which the discretion is intended to serve and also suggested that guidelines be introduced for the exercise of discretion for the achievement of that purpose.

The review was conducted by attorneys Sydney Bennett, KC and Anthea Smith.

Related Articles

Actor Tom Hanks told Harvard University graduates to be superheroes in their defense of truth and American ideals, and to resist those who twist the truth for their own gain
The Sussexes' Royal Rebound: Could Harry and Meghan Markle Return to the UK?
A provocative study suggests: Left-Wing Extremism and its Unsettling Connection to Psychopathy and Narcissism
France Arrests 10 on Suspicion of Failing to Respond in Time to Migrant Drowning
Neuralink Receives FDA Approval for First-in-Human Clinical Study
Is Saudi Arabia the holiest place in the world? Ancient Hebrew Inscriptions from "The Mount Sinai Stand" Discovered in Saudi Arabia
Ukrainian Intelligence Official Admits to Assassination Attempts on Putin
Bernard Arnault Loses $11.2 Billion in One Day as Investors Fear Slowdown in US Growth Will Reduce Demand for Luxury Products
Russian’s Wagner Group leader: “I am not a chef, I am a butcher. Russia is in danger of a revolution like in 1917.”
TikTok Sues Montana Over Law Banning the App
Ron DeSantis Jumps Into 2024 Presidential Race, Setting Up Showdown With Trump
Last Walmart in North Portland Closing Down
Florida's DeSantis seeks to disqualify judge in Disney case
Talks between US House Republicans and President Biden's Democratic administration on raising the federal government's $31.4tn debt ceiling have paused
Biden Administration Eyeing High-Profile Visits to China: The Biden Administration is heating things up by looking into setting up a series of top-level visits to Beijing by top officials in the coming months
New evidence in special counsel probe may undercut Trump’s claim documents he took were automatically declassified
A French court of appeals confirmed former President Nicolas Sarkozy's three-year jail term for corruption and influence peddling
Debt Ceiling Crises Have Unleashed Political Chaos
Weibao Wang, a former software engineer at Apple, was charged with stealing trade secrets related to autonomous systems, including self-driving cars
Mobile phone giant Vodafone to cut 11,000 jobs globally over three years as new boss says its performance not good enough
Elon Musk compares George Soros to Magneto, the supervillain from the Marvel Comics series.
Warren Buffett Sells TSMC Shares Over Concerns About Taiwan's Stability
New Study Finds That Secondary Bacterial Pneumonia Is a Major Cause of Death in COVID-19 Patients Who Require Ventilator Assistance
The Prime Minister of St. Vincent and the Grenadines calls the British monarchy "an absurdity" he wants to remove in his lifetime
King Charles III being crowned.
'Godfather Of AI' Geoffrey Hinton Quits Google To Warn Of The Tech's Dangers
A Real woman
Vermont Man Charged with Stalking After Secretly Tracking Woman with Apple AirTag
Elon Musk Statements About Tesla Autopilot Could Be 'Deepfakes,' Lawyers Claim. Judge Evette Pennypacker Does Not Understand How Far and Advanced This Technology Became
Ukraine More Prepared for Counterattack as Reinforcements Arrive
UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak and Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni Discuss Migration, Defence, and Ukraine
AT&T's Successful Test of Satellite-Based Phone Call Raises Possibility of Widespread Coverage
CNN: "Joe Biden is asking for four more years — when 74% of Americans think the country is heading the wrong way“
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan Cuts Short Live TV Interview Due to Health Issue
US Congresswoman threaten Twitter Files journalist with arrest
Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Seymour Hersh slams New York Times' pro-government stance and treatment of sources
Enough is enough: it's time to end the war in Ukraine. While Russia may be to blame for starting it, Russia is not the one refusing to stop it
Fox News Settles their case with Dominion Voting Systems for a staggering $787.5 MILLION
AG decries scapegoating and rushed lawmaking by government
The land of the free violence
21-year-old Massachusetts Air National Guard member Jack Teixeira has been arrested for leaking classified Pentagon Documents
The Supreme Court will allow a 12-year-old transgender West Virginia girl to compete on her middle school’s girls' sports teams amid a lawsuit over a ban
Bank of America cuts short conference after outrage at Ukraine comments
Revealed: royals took more than £1bn income from controversial estates
Mitt Romney calls Trump indictment 'overreach,' says charges were 'stretched' to suit a 'political agenda'
The G-7 aims to make global crypto regulations tougher
Don’t Dismiss China’s Peacemaking Bid
China and Brazil have signed a new deal that will allow them to trade in their own currencies, bypassing the US dollar as an intermediary
Elon Musk and Others Call for Pause on A.I., Citing ‘Profound Risks to Society’
Nashville style execution