Nicholls swept most of the individual accolades, including Best Interview, Best Swimwear, Best Performing Talent and Best Modeling Skills in Evening Wear.
Additionally, Nicholls was adjudged Most True to the Theme.
The First Runner Up was Chronna Khan of Trinidad and Tobago, while Second Runner Up was Wenia Verneuil of Saint Lucia, who won Most Photogenic, Best in Cultural Wear and Best Dressed in Evening Wear.
Miss Haiti, Emmanuella Michel, was adjudged Miss Congeniality.
The Virgin Islands was represented by Miss British Virgin Islands 2021, Kathlyn Archibald-Drew.
Other contestants were Briana Anthony of Antigua and Barbuda and Nia St Claire of Montserrat.
The VI was represented by Miss BVI 2021 Kathlyn Archibald-Drew at the 2022 Miss Jaycees Queen Show in Antigua.